.
Feedback

Allowances

Should kids get them?

If you give your kids an allowance—how much?

Do you have conditions, such as completion of household chores tied to earning their allowance? Do you use the allowance as a way to teach kids how to manage money?

For the past few years, I have given my kids a small allowance equal to half their grade level (example: my eighth grader gets $4/week). This year, I gave my son a raise to $10/week. My kids have chores they are expected to do, but I don’t tie them to their allowance.

I have a standing chore they can do to earn extra money—washing my car—but those of you who see me driving around town know that my kids don’t think it’s worth their time to do as frequently as I would like. I also come up with extra projects they can earn money for doing from time to time.

I wish I could teach my kids more about money management. I’ve read those articles about having a separate jar for savings—gifts, charity, discretionary (or some variation on that)—but  we’ve never had the discipline to do that.

Often they will remind me that I have not given them an allowance in a few weeks, and I find myself paying them monthly versus weekly. We still pay for many things for them—birthday party gifts, movie tickets, school lunches.

Sadly, it seems like allowance has come to be used to buy the things I say, “No!” to.  My daughter will use her allowance on what I consider frivolous things such as overnight shipping charges (for that mail-ordered shirt that she feels she MUST get in time to wear next week) or over-priced snacks at the airport gift shop.

I watched some of Susie Orman’s Money Class on KQED and learned I’m doing it all wrong, according to her:

  • Strike the word Allowance—call it Work pay or Salary. 
  • Do not tie work pay to age—tie it to the work they do. Don’t allow them to feel entitled to the pay.
  • Make a set of chores they are expected to do (with their input and agreement) as their household contribution to repay you for providing food and shelter.
  • Make a list of additional chores they can do to earn money. These chores should have dollar amounts tied to them, but can only be earned after completing the set chores.
  • Set a regular day/time for paying with consistency. Longer periods of time between payment as the kids get older, to teach them to budget and manage their money to last to the next pay day.

I’m thinking of revamping my “Work Pay” program accordingly. Whether my car will get washed more often remains to be seen!

Parents—please describe your allowance/work pay systems, and share your successes/challenges/lessons learned.

And if you do not give your kids an allowance/work pay—why not?

Newsletter & Alerts

Get the best stories each day and important breaking news

Subscribe

Not from Cupertino Patch? Find your Local Patch »

Loading comments ...
Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors. Write a new post... What's up? Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell something
A Chinese-American couple will dress just like their mainstream American counterparts at the wedding.
Crystal Tai May 1, 2011 at 06:28 pm
Thank you very much for you kind words, Priyanka! The answer to your question is in another articleRead More I wrote for Cupertino Patch, "Five Wedding Reception Venues in Cupertino." Thanks again!
Priyanka Sharma-Sindhar April 27, 2011 at 08:21 pm
This is definitely very useful for the those of us who aren't Chinese, but do have Chinese friends..Read More Thank you, Crystal. What are the popular spots in Cupertino for Chinese weddings?
Anne Ernst (Editor) April 3, 2013 at 12:59 pm
It's difficult to know what's going on in a kid's mind unless they feel confident enough to open upRead More and talk. And this program helps us adults to learn to listen differently.
Debbie Reiley April 3, 2013 at 03:50 am
I too was at this Challenge Day. It was my 6th. I first volunteered because I watched the programRead More on MTV "If You Really Knew Me" when my son was being severely bullied in middle school and saw the program was offered when he was a freshman in high school. My company strongly supports me volunteering for this and allows me to take the day off work to attend. I am continually humbled by what these teens share and saddened at what some of them have experienced in their short lives. This program is so valuable. I think every school should offer it and every parent should attend. It helps us to realize that we need to think twice before we judge or assume things about others when we know nothing about them. It is the volunteering opportunity that I look forward to participating in every year.
Anne Ernst (Editor) March 30, 2013 at 06:30 am
Carrie, Thanks for allowing me to be a part of it again.
Janice Chua March 28, 2013 at 06:45 pm
It was fun hosting you all at Bitter+Sweet, Anne!
Loy Oppus-Moe March 28, 2013 at 02:40 pm
A big "Thank You" to Anne, Pete, and 53 other professionals who opened up their companiesRead More and organizations to give our students hands-on experience of what life might look like for them post-high school. Job Shadowing brings relevance to education!